10
« on: April 13, 2018, 04:31:52 pm »
Respectfully, Jack, I submit that one needs to look at the events from the perspective of the 5 year-old child. His mother was present at the paddling session in the principal’s office and pretended she was texting to be able to video the entire event. Now, the kid had missed some 18 days of school during the year, and that violated the attendance statutes, and she ended up going to jail. At school, this day, the child had run around wild and then, when caught by some teacher, spit on the teacher (may have been the principal). That then brought on the paddling, per school policy.
The mother said that the boy was NOT spanked at home, and when he acted up, the dad just “waved [she made a ‘pfft’ sound] at his leg.” I interpreted this to imply the boy is a single child, BTW, and one who is at least somewhat molly-coddled. But, then again, we are talking about a 5 year-older here!
Now, the paddle they used was like a fraternity paddle; it was about 2 to 2.5 feet long! And, when the paddle was swung, it did make a very loud sound, amplifying the experience for the child’s mind. To a 5 year-older who was never before spanked at all before this, Jack, this had to be terrifying. They also reported that after this incident in the principal’s office, the boy was terrified to go back to that school. They said the boy “hates the school.”
Frankly, I went to school in a state where it is a felony for a teacher to strike a pupil, except, of course, in parochial and private schools. When I met a boy who went to a parochial school, and he told me what went on there, I honestly thought he was pulling my leg. I refused to believe that anyone other than a parent would ever strike a child.
I was never in a school system that allowed paddling, and I won't debate the pros or cons of it. But, if the school does something that causes any child to be so frightened of school that they are unwilling to return, well, something is seriously wrong in that situation. And, in that case, the school has totally failed in its mission, IMO.
I do not recall at what age I was first hand spanked, but I will guess it was age 4 or 5 and was likely a pop or two, where the sound was more than the actual hit. But, again, it was with a hand, and not a 2 or 2.5 foot-long paddle. This 5 year-older had no doubt played with other kids and they had talked about their pants coming down for spanking (at home) and he must have confused the situations. But that does not really matter here. The boy was so frightened of that huge and ridiculously large paddle that he was forever traumatized. IDK, Jack, but if that is not educational malpractice, it is awful darned close!